An interventional study to compare the effect of teaching on lecture method and the use of educational package on the knowledge and performance of health care providers

Document Type : Original Article


1 Health Center Number one, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

2 Department of Medical Education, School of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

3 Nursing and Midwifery Care Research Center, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

4 Department of Medical Surgical Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran


Background: Health care providers are considered as a group of primary health service workers increasing their scientific and practical ability. Providing an effective and desirable teaching is one of the main ways to improve the quality of services; however, this will be possible by selecting an appropriate training method. Therefore, the goal of this study was to determine the effect of teaching the principles of caring for pregnant mothers on knowledge and health care providers' performance with on-site and non-attendance methods.
Methods: This study was conducted as an interventional and semi-experimental study in 2017-2018. Sixty four health care providers were enrolled in Mashhad's health center. They were randomly divided into two groups of 32. For the non-attendance group, the educational package contents were prepared in the form of PowerPoint slides consisting texts and images. For the on-site teaching group, the participants were taught in lecture for six hours. The amount of knowledge of health care providers was assessed before and after training by using a written test questionnaire and their performance at work was controlled by a checklist
Results: By comparing the scores before and after the educational intervention, the difference in mean scores in the on-site group was 4.50 ± 0.334 and in the non-attending group was 3.77 ± 0.332. This difference in the values in each group was significant. The difference between the mean post-test scores in the two groups was 0.70 ± 0. 463. The difference in the mean of functional scores with two types of training was determined 17.1 ± 0.246, and no significant difference was found for the groups (p = 0.496).
Conclusion: In this study, the increase in the level of health care information was acceptable. Both methods had the same effect in the cognitive and functional domain. Therefore, the method of using the educational package can be a good alternative to the lecture method.


1.         Kianian T, Zare M, Ildarabadi E, Karimi Mooanaghi H, Saber S. Evaluation of training competency of healt care works in training clients and patients. Journal of nursing training 2014;3(1):51-60. Persian.
2.         Office MH. Mothers' Health: Ministry of health, treatment and medical training; 2005. Persian.
3.         Akbar SA. Instructions for the Mother's death process and Expectations from the universities. Tehran University of Medical Sciences; 2017.  Contract No. 3697. Persian.
4.         Office MH. Chart booklet maternal care 7ed. Tehran: Ministry of health, treatment  and  medical  training 2016. Persian.
5.         Ameh CA, van den Broek N. Training health-care providers in emergency obstetric and newborn. Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol. 2015;29:1077-91.
6.         Nobakht  M, Gholami H, Emadzadeh A,  Momeni Rad S. A survey on the quality of master of medical education  E-learning Course at Mashhad University of Medical Sciences. Journal of of Medical Education and Development 2017;11(4): 287-300. Persian.
7.         Zianezad U,  Heidari M, Ghodusi Borujeni M, Naseh L. A Comparative Study on the Effects of Verbal and Non-verbal Education on the Knowledge and Attitude of Soldiers Regarding the Transmission and Prevention of AIDS. Journal of Military Medicine 2014;16(3):169- 77. Persian.
8.         Nastiezaie N, Hezaremogadam M. A comparative  survey on effects of face toface and distanced short term traning  courses on staff’s psychological  empowerment. Journal of Urmia Nursing And Midwifery Faculty. 2010;8(4):254-65. Persian.
9.         Mahdizadeh H, Azizi M. The challlenges in  application of information technologies (ICT) in medical science universities. Journal of Healt System Research 2011;6(4):589-600. Persian.
10.       Karanjam S, Zarif N. The comparison of the effect of traditional and off–line electronic educational methods on the knowledge and attitude of the undergraduate dental students of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences. Interdisciplinary Journal of Virtual Learning in Medical Sciences. 2015;6(3):20-30. Persian.
11.       Sadeghi A, Rezazadeh S. Attitude and performance of healt staff regarding healt information resources, Kerman University of Medical Siences. Journal of Education and Community Healt 2014;1(1):25-35. Persian.
12.       Mardegan KJ ,  Schofield MJMurphy GC. Comparison of an interactive CD-based and traditional instructor-led basic life support skills training for nurses. Aust Crit Care. 2015;28(3):160-7.
13.       Sharifi F,   Feyzi A, Arteshehdar E. Knowledge and Satisfaction of Medical Students with Two Methods of Educationfor Endocrine Pathophysiology Course: E-Learning and Lecture in Classroom. Journal of Medical Education Development 2013;6(11):30-40. Persian.
14.       Ebadi A, Yousefi Goshtasb Sh, Khaghanizadeh M, Hosseini MJ, Raeisifar A, Masoumi M, et al. Comparison of conventional and distance training on nurses' clinical skills. Iranian Journal of Military Medicine. 2010;12(9):71-4.
15.       Aggarwal R,  Gupte N,  Kass N,  Taylor H, Ali J,  Bhan A, et al. A comparison of online versus on-site Training in Health Research Methodology. BMC Medical Education. 2011; 11:37: 2-10.
16.       Abutarbush SMNaylor JMParchoma GD'Eon MPetrie LCarruthers T. Evaluation of traditional instruction versus a self-Learning computer maduale in teachining veterinary students how to pass a nasogastric tube in the hourse. J Vet Med Educ. 2006;33(3):447-54.
17.       Enayati T, Rayatnejad Sh. Investigating the effect of in-person and non-attendance training on employee learning. Journal of Process Engineering 2015;2(10):137-50. Persian.
18.       Hashemi J, Jamshidian S, Haghani F. Comparing the effects of “lecture” and “simulated patient” teaching methods on promoting the knowledge and performance of health care providers. Iranian Journal of Medical Education. 2017;17(29):145-56. Persian.